Need to check the ingredient order on a new label? Review AFVA's food labelling review service or contact AFVA for free initial guidance.
A finished label may contain only one short ingredient list. The evidence behind its order can include a weighed recipe, processing losses, reconstitution instructions and several supplier specifications. Copying the previous artwork does not establish that a changed recipe is still represented correctly.
This guide helps New Zealand food businesses organise that evidence. It focuses on the ordering decision, rather than repeating the whole set of food-labelling requirements or the separate rules for declaring small amounts of compound ingredients.
Quick answer. Start with the current weighed recipe and list ingredients by ingoing weight, subject to the specific Code rules. Record added water and relevant processing losses, identify any reconstitution basis, and decide how compound ingredients will be represented. Keep the calculation and supplier evidence with the exact artwork version. Do not rearrange the list by how much an ingredient seems to contribute after cooking.
1. Build one controlled recipe record first
Use the recipe actually made, with consistent units and quantities. Identify the product, batch size, version, date and responsible person. Record bought-in ingredients by their exact supplier specification, not an informal name that could describe several products. A recipe in cups and handfuls is a poor starting point for a weight-based ordering exercise.
The FSANZ ingredient-list guidance explains descending order by ingoing weight. The current Food Standards Code Standard 1.2.4 provides the operative ordering provisions and specific exceptions.
As a practical control, create a worksheet connecting each proposed label ingredient to its recipe entry and evidence. If the same purchased ingredient has several possible formulations, establish which one is authorised before finalising the list. Resolve uncertain inputs first; sorting uncertain numbers more neatly does not improve their reliability.
2. Separate ingoing weights from finished-food measurements
For an ordinary ordering calculation, the starting point is the weight going into manufacture. Do not simply rank ingredients using the cooked product's appearance or a finished-yield estimate. Ingredient percentage declarations, nutrition calculations and ingredient order are related tasks, but one calculation should not silently substitute for another.
For example, a hypothetical sauce uses 30 kg of one ingredient and 20 kg of another. Their relative ingoing weights provide an ordering starting point. If cooking later reduces the batch weight, do not infer from that alone that those two ingredients have changed places. Added water and volatile ingredients need the specific treatment below.
Keep both the batch input sheet and the yield record. Where the recipe and production record disagree, investigate the discrepancy before treating the draft ingredient list as final.
Three records that answer different questions
Record
Weighed recipe
What it shows
The ingredients and quantities intended to go into manufacture.
Check
Confirm the version and actual production use.
Record
Process and yield record
What it shows
Relevant losses, additions and the resulting batch quantity.
Check
Explain the evidence used for water or volatile-ingredient treatment.
Record
Supplier specification
What it shows
The identity and composition of a bought-in ingredient.
Check
Match the specification to the purchased formulation.
3. Account for added water without inventing a loss
Water added during manufacture needs deliberate review. The Code has a specific calculation for the ingoing weight of water and volatile ingredients, accounting for removal and water used for reconstitution. It also provides defined circumstances in which added water need not be separately listed. These include water used to reconstitute dehydrated or concentrated ingredients, water within declared broth, brine or syrup, and added water constituting less than 5% of the food.
These are conditional provisions, not permission to delete water whenever a product is cooked. Prepare records showing how much was added, what the process removed and what supported any reconstitution allocation. Ask the reviewer to confirm how the provision applies to your formula.
If losses vary between small kitchen trials and commercial runs, make that uncertainty visible. A guess about evaporation should not become an undocumented permanent label assumption. Keep the calculation basis and supporting production evidence together.
4. Distinguish two reconstitution situations
A concentrated ingredient reconstituted during manufacture is different from a finished product that the purchaser is instructed to reconstitute. Standard 1.2.4 provides options for these situations: an ingredient reconstituted during manufacture may use its weight before dehydration or concentration; a food represented for reconstitution may order ingredients on the reconstituted basis if that basis is made clear on the label.
Do not apply either option automatically. Give the reviewer the concentrate specification, intended reconstitution ratio, actual water additions and preparation directions. Record the chosen basis so the person updating the next recipe can reproduce it.
A practical question is: what exactly has been reconstituted, by whom and at which stage? Answering that question helps prevent the same water being counted twice, or a dry-product list being changed to a prepared basis without the required explanation.
5. Choose a consistent compound-ingredient approach
Bought-in sauces, seasonings or pastes may themselves contain several ingredients. For food other than food for infants, the Code allows a compound ingredient to be represented by its name with the applicable bracketed ingredients, or by listing its components individually as ingredients of the final food. The ordering calculation must follow the chosen approach. Food for infants has a specific restriction on the named compound-ingredient option and needs separate review.
For a hypothetical purchased paste, a supplier's sub-ingredient list alone may establish relative order within the paste but not the exact quantities needed to distribute its components through the whole product's list. Ask for the information required by the calculation, or have the reviewer assess the suitable presentation. Do not invent percentages from list position.
The details of the under-5% exception, continuing mandatory declarations and relevant additives are covered in the separate compound ingredients under five percent guide. A small inclusion is not a reason to stop reviewing the specification or allergen information.
6. Prepare this ingredient-order review checklist
These are recommended review records, rather than a prescribed statutory form.
- Current product and recipe version, with all inputs in consistent weight units.
- Actual manufacturing additions and any relevant rework details.
- Batch size, process description and evidence for relevant losses.
- Added-water calculation and the basis for any omission.
- Concentrate specifications, reconstitution calculations and purchaser directions where relevant.
- Current compound-ingredient specifications and the chosen listing approach.
- Proposed ingredient names and any required additive declarations for separate review.
- A link between the calculation, allergen review and exact artwork version.
- A named person to resolve missing data and approve the final business decision.
Check allergen declarations independently. The FSANZ allergen labelling guidance describes the required declaration format and conditions. A correct weight order does not establish that ingredient names, bolding or the separate allergen summary are correct.
7. Recheck the list when the recipe or supplier changes
Common mistakes include using a trial recipe after production has changed, sorting by finished weight, omitting added water without evidence and treating a supplier substitution as an artwork-only change. Another is forgetting that a new compound ingredient can change allergen information even when its inclusion rate stays the same.
Set a simple change trigger: when an ingredient, quantity, specification, process or preparation direction changes, ask which label calculations need review. Keep the previous evidence and record why the revised list is different. The ingredient substitution approval guide covers the broader change decision.
Before printing, compare the final artwork against the reviewed version. Avoid making an apparently minor last-minute wording change without checking its effect on ingredient identification or mandatory declarations. The business remains responsible for the food and its label.
Frequently asked questions
Do ingredients go in order of their finished cooked weight?
The general rule is descending ingoing weight, subject to the Code's specific provisions. Added water, volatile ingredients and reconstitution need their own review; appearance or cooked yield alone is not the ordering method.
Can added water always be left off a cooked product's label?
No. Apply the relevant calculation and conditions using supporting evidence. Cooking by itself does not establish an omission. Record additions, relevant losses and any reconstitution basis.
Can I estimate a purchased sauce's percentages from its ingredient list?
Do not turn descending order into invented exact percentages. Obtain the supplier information needed for the intended calculation or ask the reviewer to assess an appropriate compound-ingredient presentation.
Does an ingredient below 5% disappear from the list?
There is no general rule allowing every ingredient below 5% to be omitted. Specific added-water and compound-ingredient provisions have conditions, and mandatory declarations can continue to apply.
Does an AFVA label review mean regulatory approval?
No. AFVA provides a scoped review and practical recommendations. A review is not regulatory approval, and the food business retains responsibility for the final formulation, label and compliance.
How AFVA can help
AFVA can review the proposed ingredient list alongside the recipe, supplier specifications and artwork. Bring the supporting calculations and identify uncertainties about water, concentrates or bought-in mixtures. This helps the review focus on the evidence behind the order, rather than guessing from a finished label. Any review is within an agreed scope and is not regulatory approval.
General New Zealand food-labelling guidance, researched 21 November 2026. Confirm applicability, exceptions and all required declarations for the particular product. The food business remains responsible for its formulation, label and compliance.
Need Practical Food Safety Support for Your Business?
Contact us for free initial guidance. We provide practical, plain-English food safety support for New Zealand food businesses across all service areas.
This article provides general information only and is not a substitute for professional advice specific to your situation. Contact us for guidance based on your actual food activities and requirements.