Need help with this food safety decision? Review AFVA’s food safety audit preparation support or contact AFVA for free initial guidance.
A food metal-detector challenge check can fail even when the preceding production records appear routine. At that point the business needs a clear connection between the failed check, the control it was intended to demonstrate and the food that may be affected.
This guide is for New Zealand production and quality teams reviewing that response. It helps organise records and decisions. It provides no machine operating method, test-piece size, sensitivity setting or universal checking frequency. Follow the approved equipment instructions and the food safety system applying to the actual line.
Quick answer. Follow the site's failure procedure, bring the affected operation under control and identify potentially affected food. Preserve the failed and preceding checks, production and stock records, and evidence about the fault. Have the appropriate people assess the product boundary and disposition. Confirm equipment recovery and the authority to restart separately from the decision about stock already produced.
Identify what the failed check was meant to show
Record the exact observation. Was an agreed challenge not detected, did the expected rejection fail, or did another required part of the check fail? Keep the result, time, product, equipment identity, operator and relevant check reference. A description such as ‘detector issue’ makes later assessment harder.
Check how the activity fits your actual system. Metal detection may be a control at a critical control point, or it may sit within another defined control arrangement. The control classification, required performance and corrective action come from the applicable hazard assessment and procedures. This article does not classify every detector as a CCP.
The Codex General Principles of Food Hygiene, section 13.2.5, describes physical-contamination prevention and appropriately calibrated detection or screening where necessary. Its HACCP sections connect monitoring and corrective action to the control actually established.
Control the operation and preserve the stock status
Use the failure procedure to stop further potentially affected production or dispatch as appropriate, inform the responsible people and secure the suspect stock. Maintain any storage conditions the food requires. Make the status clear physically and in the stock system so people cannot select it as ordinary available product.
MPI’s Good Operating Practice guidance for non-conforming product describes identifying affected food, controlling its use and assigning appropriate disposition authority. The guidance is dated August 2011. Use its general control principles with the current requirements of your own programme and reporting arrangements.
Record where the food is now. Include work in progress, packed stock, product transferred to another area, rework and stock already dispatched where relevant. An equipment reset does not establish what happened to those quantities.
Build a reasoned boundary for potentially affected food
Start with the most recent satisfactory check that is relevant to the failed function and the product being considered. Identify production between that evidence and discovery of the failure. Then review whether the fault history, product changes, maintenance or other information requires the scope to extend further.
The previous satisfactory entry is an investigation reference. It does not automatically prove the detector worked continuously afterwards, or settle an earlier period if the investigation questions that entry. Where monitoring was not continuous, Codex section 19.10 says the operator should determine which product may have been affected by a CCP deviation.
Map the proposed time window to actual batch, pack and stock identifiers. If a code covers a longer period, explain how the affected quantity is distinguished. Retain uncertainty where records do not support a narrower boundary rather than choosing the smallest convenient lot.
Decisions and supporting evidence
Evidence group
Performance history
Records to connect
Last relevant satisfactory check, failed check, faults and intervening changes.
Question to resolve
Which part of the control is in doubt, and since when?
Evidence group
Production and movement
Records to connect
Product, batches, times, quantities, rework, stock locations and dispatch references.
Question to resolve
Which food passed through the affected arrangement and where is it?
Evidence group
Investigation and disposition
Records to connect
Findings, corrective action, technical assessment, authorised stock outcome and restart checks.
Question to resolve
What supports each decision, and what remains unresolved?
Keep equipment recovery and food disposition as separate decisions
A competent equipment specialist may need to investigate the fault and restore the defined function. Record the work performed and the evidence that the approved checks were completed under the relevant conditions. Apply the site's restart authority and instructions before returning to normal operation.
The food produced before control was demonstrated still needs its own assessment. Codex section 19.10 describes segregation, safety assessment and appropriate disposition of potentially affected food after a CCP deviation. That assessment may need external expertise. A later satisfactory check contributes evidence about the condition tested at that time. It does not, on its own, clear earlier stock.
Where a further inspection or other treatment is proposed for held product, have the appropriate specialist assess whether it is suitable for the actual food, packaging, suspected issue and control limitations. Document the authorised method and outcome through the applicable system. The procedure used for a routine production check is not automatically a validated recovery process.
Use a hypothetical timeline to test the records
Example only. A required challenge is recorded as satisfactory at 10 am. A later challenge fails at midday. The stock system contains two packing codes and some product moved to another storage area during that period. A restart check is later satisfactory after investigation.
The team links the check records to the actual production and movement records. It assesses whether the suspected cause supports that initial two-hour window or requires more investigation. Each affected quantity remains identifiable while its outcome is decided. The times illustrate a record problem and set no required checking interval.
If the response file contains only the midday failure and later pass, it leaves the product scope and decision trail incomplete. Add the evidence explaining what was controlled, assessed and done with the food. A completed machine-service job is one part of that file.
Escalate uncertainty and check that the response worked
If potentially affected product has left the site's control, use the applicable incident and reporting arrangements promptly. Assess the food, hazard, distribution and evidence with the responsible people. The Food Act 2014 primary duty requires people trading in food to ensure it is safe and suitable. An internal response form does not replace that responsibility.
Review why the failure occurred and whether the monitoring or response procedure needs improvement. Connect repairs, instructions and staff training to a follow-up check of effectiveness. AFVA’s corrective-action effectiveness guide explains that later review.
For an object already reported by a customer, use the separate foreign-matter complaint investigation guide to preserve the original material and packaging. This article addresses a failed preventive equipment check and the associated stock decisions.
Prepare a response file someone else can follow
- Exact failed function, observation, check reference, product, equipment and timing.
- The relevant prior checks and evidence used to define the affected scope.
- Identified batches, quantities, locations and any stock already supplied.
- Actual containment, investigation and equipment-work records.
- Separate restart and product-disposition decisions with their evidence and authority.
- Follow-up actions, unresolved matters and effectiveness review.
Common errors include replacing the first result with the later pass, treating a repair as the product decision, and closing the event while some affected quantity remains unaccounted for. Preserve the original records and explain changes or corrections openly.
Frequently asked questions
Does a failed challenge prove that metal is present in the food?
It establishes a failure to demonstrate the required performance under that check. Investigate what that means for the control and potentially affected product. Neither confirmed contamination nor a safe-product conclusion follows from that observation alone.
How far back should the product hold extend?
Assess the relevant performance history and production records under the failure procedure. The last applicable satisfactory check is a starting reference, and the cause or missing evidence may require the scope to extend further.
Can we release earlier stock after the detector passes again?
A later pass does not complete the earlier-product assessment. The authorised person needs evidence supporting the disposition of the food already produced, including any suitable further work required by the system.
What test-piece sizes and checking interval should we use?
Use the validated control requirements, product and packaging conditions, equipment instructions and applicable scheme or programme. This guide supplies no universal size or frequency for all food operations.
Does every failure require a recall?
The response depends on the possible hazard, affected food, distribution and applicable reporting requirements. If stock has been supplied or the risk is unclear, escalate promptly through the site's incident arrangements and obtain appropriate advice.
What can AFVA review before an audit?
AFVA can review the procedure, response records, stock-decision trail and corrective-action evidence within an agreed food safety audit preparation scope. Equipment repair and specialist performance assessment need the appropriate provider.
How AFVA can help
Send AFVA the relevant procedure, check history, production timeline, stock reconciliation and redacted response records. Identify whether the question concerns the hold boundary, missing evidence, decision authority or corrective-action follow-up. Agree the review scope and any equipment-specialist input before work begins.
General information only. Confirm the requirements that apply to your specific food activities, products, processes, locations and sales model.
Need Practical Food Safety Support for Your Business?
Contact us for free initial guidance. We provide practical, plain-English food safety support for New Zealand food businesses across all service areas.
This article provides general information only and is not a substitute for professional advice specific to your situation. Contact us for guidance based on your actual food activities and requirements.