๐Ÿ“ Auckland, New Zealand โœ‰ info@foodverification.co.nz ๐Ÿ“ž 0221281203
New Zealand-wide service Free Initial Guidance โ†’

Food Supplier Specification Deviations NZ โ€” Control a Temporary Concession

15 November 2026  ·  Food Safety Consulting

Quality manager reviews a delivery document beside a sealed ingredient bag at a separate receiving bench.

Need help with this food safety decision? Review AFVA’s food safety and quality consulting or contact AFVA for free initial guidance.

A supplier may ask you to accept a particular food lot despite a departure from the agreed specification. The request might concern an administrative discrepancy, a quality characteristic or an issue with possible safety consequences. Calling it a temporary concession does not decide which of those situations you have.

This guide focuses on the controlled exception after a discrepancy has been identified. AFVA’s delivery acceptance guide covers the arrival checks, while the supplier certificate of analysis guide explains how to match a report to a lot. Here the question is how to define, assess, authorise and close a proposed temporary exception.

Quick answer. Identify the exact deviation, affected lot and proposed use. Assess safety, suitability, legal and customer requirements before considering an exception. Keep the stock status controlled, record the evidence and authorised decision, and define the quantity, conditions and end point. A concession cannot waive a legal requirement or turn an unsupported safety assumption into evidence.

Describe the departure from the current specification

Record the approved requirement, specification version and the actual observation or result. Identify the supplier, material, lot, delivered quantity and location. State whether the discrepancy was found before receipt, during checking or after the material had already been used. Preserve the original result and supplier message.

Separate a confirmed difference from missing information. A late report is a documentation gap. A reported value outside the agreed range is a result to assess. Conflicting lot identifiers leave uncertainty about which material the evidence describes. Those situations can require different follow-up.

The Codex General Principles of Food Hygiene, section 13.2.8, recommends procuring ingredients to specification and checking safety and suitability compliance where necessary. A concession record should show how the departure was assessed against the intended use, including any control assumptions that could be affected.

Separate the decision questions before considering use

First ask whether the food remains safe and suitable and meets applicable legal requirements. Then identify the customer or internal specification requirement and who has authority over it. A customer’s commercial agreement and a competent technical assessment answer different questions. Both may be needed.

Section 14 of the Food Act 2014 requires a person trading in food to ensure it is safe and suitable. An internal signature or supplier credit cannot displace that duty. Where the question involves an allergen, contaminant, changed control condition or unsupported claim, obtain appropriate assessment rather than treating the concession form as the answer.

The following review categories are suggested prompts. They are not an approval scale, and describing an issue as quality does not establish that it has no safety or suitability effect.

Decisions and supporting evidence

Question

What is uncertain?

Evidence to obtain

The actual requirement, original observation or result, correct lot and relevant intended use.

Decision boundary

An evidence gap stays visible until it is resolved.

Question

What could the departure affect?

Evidence to obtain

Relevant safety, suitability, process, label, claim and customer information.

Decision boundary

Commercial pressure cannot replace a technical assessment.

Question

Who can decide the outcome?

Evidence to obtain

The authorised technical role and any required customer, scheme or authority input.

Decision boundary

A supplier request is a proposal until the applicable decision is made.

Define the concession’s quantity, use and end point

If an exception is justified and permitted, make its boundaries explicit. Identify the lot and quantity covered, the exact departure accepted, the products or uses allowed, any conditions to complete first, the person authorising it and when the permission ends. Keep the rationale and supporting evidence with the record.

Avoid open wording such as ‘acceptable until further notice’. A date alone may also be insufficient if staff cannot tell which remaining stock it covers. State what happens to unused material at the end point and who checks that outcome. Where an approval depends on a condition, keep the material’s status consistent with whether the condition has actually been completed.

A limited exception should not silently rewrite the standard specification. If the supplier proposes the new condition for routine supply, route it through the appropriate specification and change-review process. The ingredient substitution review is relevant when the material or intended formulation is changing.

Connect the decision to the physical lot and stock system

Keep held, accepted, rejected and otherwise restricted quantities identifiable. If part of a delivery has a different outcome, record the split and its location. Make the approved use clear to purchasing, stores, production and dispatch so a stock entry does not accidentally make restricted material available for any product.

MPI’s Good Operating Practice guidance on non-conforming product describes identifying affected food, controlling its use or dispatch and assigning appropriate release authority. It is dated August 2011 and remains hosted by MPI as guidance. Its older organisational names do not replace current reporting arrangements or the specific requirements of your programme.

Record the actual movement and use of material against the concession reference. A signed approval is difficult to audit if the business cannot show which lots or finished batches relied on it. If the material was already used, assess the affected products and any reporting or incident-response needs promptly through the applicable procedure.

Work through an example without assuming the outcome

Hypothetical example. A supplier offers one lot of the usual approved ingredient with a particle-size result outside the agreed range. Purchasing asks for a one-off acceptance to meet a production deadline. The technical reviewer first identifies which products would use it and whether particle size matters to processing, the finished-product specification or another control assumption.

The business keeps the lot status clear while evidence is assessed. Any supported exception is then limited to identified material and defined use, with the appropriate decision and conditions recorded. The example does not establish that the lot can be accepted. It demonstrates why the same request can require more than agreement on price or delivery.

When several concessions involve the same requirement, review the pattern. Repeated exceptions may point to a specification that needs justified review, a supplier capability issue or a control that is being bypassed. Investigate the reason before extending the next exception.

Close the exception with a visible outcome

Before closing the record, check what happened to every affected quantity, whether the conditions were completed and whether any linked finished product remains unresolved. Record returned, disposed, used and remaining amounts as applicable. Follow up the supplier’s corrective action and keep the original evidence accessible.

Use this final checklist for the concession file.

  • Correct supplier, material, lot, quantity and specification version.
  • Exact departure and the assessment of relevant consequences.
  • Evidence reviewed, remaining uncertainties and required external input.
  • Decision-maker, date, authorised outcome and conditions.
  • Defined permitted use and end point, including remaining stock.
  • Actual stock movement, affected batch links and closure evidence.

Common mistakes include approving a request without seeing the original result, using one form for unlimited future supply, and closing the paperwork while restricted stock remains selectable. Resolve the operational handover as part of the decision.

Frequently asked questions

Can a customer accept any deviation by concession?

A customer can decide matters within its authority, but an agreement cannot waive legal duties or establish food safety without evidence. Assess the actual issue and all applicable requirements before deciding the permitted outcome.

Is a missing COA the same as an out-of-specification result?

They create different evidence questions. A missing document leaves a gap against the release requirements. An out-of-range result also requires assessment of the reported departure. Record which situation exists and what must be resolved.

Can the concession cover only part of a lot?

Any proposed split needs reliable quantity, identity, storage and permitted-use controls. The assessment must explain why the defined part can have that outcome. A convenient quantity split alone does not establish a safe boundary.

Should we change the specification after every concession?

Keep a one-off decision distinguishable from a permanent change. Review repeated requests and the evidence behind the requirement. Make any justified ongoing change through the controlled approval process.

What if the affected material has already entered production?

Identify the use, quantities and finished batches, preserve the evidence and follow the applicable product assessment and incident procedures. Do not describe a later concession as evidence that was available before use.

Can AFVA help make the procedure easier to use?

AFVA can review supplier and receiving records, specifications, non-conforming product controls and corrective actions within an agreed consulting scope. The business and any relevant authority retain their respective decisions.

How AFVA can help

Send AFVA the current specification, supplier request, original result and a redacted example of the concession record. Explain which use or closure decision is difficult. The review can focus on clear authority, evidence, stock controls and recurring supplier issues.

General information only. Confirm the requirements that apply to your specific food activities, products, processes, locations and sales model.

Need Practical Food Safety Support for Your Business?

Contact us for free initial guidance. We provide practical, plain-English food safety support for New Zealand food businesses across all service areas.

This article provides general information only and is not a substitute for professional advice specific to your situation. Contact us for guidance based on your actual food activities and requirements.

More Articles