Need help with this food safety decision? Review AFVA’s product issue investigation and result-review support or contact AFVA for free initial guidance.
A chemical food test report may show a result such as “less than 0.10 mg/kg”, or a measured concentration with an uncertainty statement. Before transferring either into a pass column, establish what the laboratory measured and what its notation means. This guide helps New Zealand food owners and quality teams review low-level chemical results, including contaminants or composition measurements. It develops the reporting question after the test has been selected.
Quick answer. Keep the reported result, qualifier, units and food basis together. Ask whether the quoted limit is a detection limit, quantification limit or another reporting threshold, and whether it is suitable for your decision. For a numerical result close to a specification, confirm the applicable decision rule and how uncertainty is handled. Retain the laboratory’s explanation before recording the conclusion.
Read the exact chemical food test result
Start with the report’s sample identity, product version, test name and method. Check whether the result describes the food as received, a dry-matter basis or another preparation. A result expressed in mg/kg and a limit expressed in mg/L cannot be compared until the basis and any necessary conversion have been resolved. The original certificate should remain visible beside your working assessment.
Confirm the quantity being measured too. A substance name, a group total and a result expressed as an equivalent compound can represent different reporting conventions. Ask the laboratory to identify the correct comparison if the specification uses different wording. The general food testing guide explains the earlier task of selecting a test to answer a defined food-safety or quality question.
Separate detection, quantification and reporting limits
Eurachem’s 2025 method validation guide explains detection and quantification as different method-performance questions. A detection limit relates to the lowest concentration that the method can detect with a specified degree of confidence. A quantification limit relates to the lowest concentration that can be measured with acceptable performance. The food matrix and the whole analytical procedure matter.
A laboratory may use a particular reporting threshold or qualification. Do not assume that every less-than symbol identifies the same type of limit, or that “not detected” means exactly zero. Ask what the notation establishes for this sample, method and intended comparison. The following questions are a review aid, rather than replacement definitions for the laboratory’s own report.
Decisions and supporting evidence
Report entry
Less than a stated concentration
Question for the laboratory
What type of limit is this, and what conclusion can be supported below it?
Record to keep
The original value, qualifier, units and written explanation.
Report entry
Detected, with a qualification
Question for the laboratory
Was the substance identified but the concentration too uncertain for ordinary quantitative reporting?
Record to keep
The meaning of the flag and any appropriate follow-up.
Report entry
Numerical concentration
Question for the laboratory
What method, basis and uncertainty information apply to the intended decision?
Record to keep
The reported number and accompanying qualifications together.
Check that the method can answer your specification
Write down the exact specification, its source, version and intended use. Identify whether it is a legal requirement, customer requirement or internal control. A laboratory method can perform correctly while still being unsuitable for the level at which your business needs an answer. Agree that level when requesting the quotation.
Consider a hypothetical internal specification with an upper limit of 0.05 mg/kg. The report returns “less than 0.10 mg/kg”. That statement alone cannot establish that the result is below 0.05 mg/kg. Ask whether an appropriate method with a lower reporting capability or other evidence is needed. These numbers illustrate the reporting gap and are not a limit for any food or substance.
For the separate question of accredited coverage, use the IANZ food laboratory scope guide. Matching the food, analyte and method scope does not remove the need to discuss reporting capability.
Handle numerical results close to a limit through the agreed rule
Measurement uncertainty describes uncertainty associated with a measured value. It is distinct from a less-than result. A numerical concentration near a specification can require an agreed approach to the risk of accepting or rejecting the item.
The Eurachem guide to uncertainty in compliance assessment explains how decision rules connect a measured value, uncertainty and specification. Some rules use simple acceptance, while others use an acceptance boundary or allow an inconclusive outcome. The appropriate rule depends on the actual requirement. ILAC’s decision-rule guidance also states that a legally mandated rule must be followed where one applies.
Ask which rule was applied to any pass or fail statement and what that statement covers. Do not subtract uncertainty from an unwelcome result, change rounding or select a different rule after seeing the number to obtain a preferred conclusion.
Keep one review record from the certificate to the decision
Use a short working record that another reviewer can follow. Identify the sample and batch, the substance or measurement, the original result and qualifier, the reporting basis, the specification and its source, and the question requiring clarification. Add the laboratory’s reply, any decision rule and the person responsible for the business decision.
Retain report revisions together and identify which version was used. If the result is entered into a nutrition worksheet, keep the analytical report beside the calculation and resolve the qualified value before producing artwork. The nutrition laboratory brief and handover guide covers that wider workflow.
Where an unclear report forms part of a possible food-safety incident, follow the applicable product-control and notification procedures promptly. A request to clarify notation does not resolve the affected food’s status.
Avoid shortcuts that hide the original evidence
Common errors include replacing a less-than result with zero, dropping the qualifier when importing data, comparing different food bases, or treating every laboratory pass statement as approval of a whole product. Preserve missing information as an open question.
A useful pre-decision check is to confirm sample identity, retain the unedited result, match units and basis, identify the specification, resolve the reporting limit, check the decision rule where relevant, and record who authorised the conclusion. These are AFVA preparation recommendations. The laboratory, responsible operator and relevant authority retain their respective roles.
Frequently asked questions
Does below detection mean the substance is absent?
It does not establish an absolute zero throughout the food or batch. Obtain the laboratory’s explanation of its detection capability and what the reported statement means for the tested sample.
Are LOD and LOQ interchangeable?
They describe different performance questions. Ask how the laboratory defines and establishes each for the method and food matrix, and which is shown on the report.
Can I enter zero in my spreadsheet for a less-than result?
Keep the original qualifier. If a particular calculation requires a convention for such results, have a competent reviewer identify and document the appropriate convention and its limitations.
Can an accredited method still have a reporting limit too high for my purpose?
Yes. Accreditation coverage and fitness for a particular comparison both need review. State the required decision level when asking the laboratory to quote.
Can I subtract uncertainty to make a result pass?
Apply the required or agreed decision rule. Selective arithmetic after seeing the result does not provide a justified conformity assessment.
Can AFVA replace the laboratory’s report?
AFVA can help review the evidence, organise questions and coordinate appropriate technical input within an agreed scope. Laboratory analysis, reporting and corrections are carried out by the laboratory.
How AFVA can help
Send the complete report, sampling and product details, specification and decision you need to make. AFVA can help organise the evidence and clarify the next questions for the laboratory or technical specialist. Agree the scope before commissioning further testing.
General information only. Confirm the requirements that apply to your specific food activities, products, processes, locations and sales model.
Need Practical Food Safety Support for Your Business?
Contact us for free initial guidance. We provide practical, plain-English food safety support for New Zealand food businesses across all service areas.
This article provides general information only and is not a substitute for professional advice specific to your situation. Contact us for guidance based on your actual food activities and requirements.