Need help with this food safety decision? Review AFVA’s shelf-life study planning and laboratory coordination support or contact AFVA for free initial guidance.
A chilled ready-to-eat product reaches a proposed date looking acceptable, and the routine samples show no detected pathogen. The next decision is whether those observations answer the safety question behind the date mark. Before ordering more tests, distinguish evidence about the commercial food during storage from evidence about how a particular microorganism can behave in it. This guide is for New Zealand manufacturers choosing the study question with a competent adviser and laboratory.
Quick answer. A durability study follows uninoculated commercial food under defined storage conditions. A challenge study introduces a target microorganism under controlled specialist conditions to investigate a defined growth, survival or treatment question. Choose according to the hazard and evidence gap. Routine non-detections alone cannot establish that a microorganism would be unable to grow if present. The complete shelf-life decision also needs relevant quality and process evidence.
Define the shelf-life decision before choosing the study
Start with the exact food, recipe, process, final pack, intended consumers and storage/distribution conditions. Record whether it is eaten without a further effective pathogen-control step. Identify what supports the proposed life already and which uncertainty remains. “We need a shelf-life test” is a starting enquiry, rather than a complete study brief.
MPI’s shelf-life guidance identifies direct studies and indirect evidence, including predictive models. It also calls for an understanding of processing and product characteristics before investigating shelf life or pathogen growth. A storage study cannot correct an uncontrolled manufacturing process. The general shelf-life guide explains the wider route from product description to date marking.
Compare durability and challenge evidence
The term durability study is used here for following commercial food without deliberately adding the target microorganism. Ask the laboratory to define the terms on its quotation and exactly what its proposed work measures. Both types of evidence may contribute to one product assessment.
Decisions and supporting evidence
Study
Durability or storage study
Question it can address
How does representative commercial food change over the defined storage period?
Evidence boundary
Findings describe the samples and conditions assessed. A pathogen absent from them cannot demonstrate its growth behaviour.
Study
Growth challenge study
Question it can address
Can the selected microorganism grow in this food under the chosen study conditions?
Evidence boundary
A competent specialist defines the organism, design, conditions and interpretation. Conclusions apply within those boundaries.
Study
Treatment challenge study
Question it can address
What effect does a defined treatment have on the selected microorganism?
Evidence boundary
This is a different validation question. A growth study does not automatically validate a lethal process.
Separate non-detection from the ability to grow
A set of routine non-detections supplies information about the material tested. It leaves a different question if the safety assessment depends on whether a pathogen could multiply during storage. The FSANZ microbiological criteria Compendium distinguishes food-safety criteria from other microbiological assessment purposes. A criterion and a study design need to fit the decision.
MPI’s Listeria management guidance describes a sequence of understanding product properties, reviewing relevant scientific evidence and, where necessary, using additional analysis, modelling or challenge trials. This supports a reasoned choice. It does not establish that every chilled product must receive the same test package.
For example, suppose a business wants to extend a chilled dip’s life. It has a quality trial and a few non-detections, but the basis for a pathogen-growth assumption is unresolved. The useful next step is to ask a competent reviewer what evidence resolves that assumption before selecting more routine time points. This is an illustrative question, rather than a safety conclusion for dip.
Specify the commercial product and conditions the study must represent
Give the laboratory the final formulation, relevant ingredient specifications, processing history, pack and proposed storage directions. Identify normal variation and any product boundary that could affect the question, such as a recipe range or different pack format. Ask what measurements and production information are needed to select a suitable study case.
Health Canada’s challenge-testing guidance for refrigerated ready-to-eat foods provides technical context on defining the study purpose, considering conditions permissive for growth and involving a food microbiologist. Its Canadian classification rules are not New Zealand requirements. The linked document is marked under review, so use it as technical background alongside current applicable NZ requirements and specialist advice.
Discuss the complete time and temperature history relevant to distribution and intended use. Have the specialist justify the conditions, batches and sampling points. A longer or warmer study is not automatically the correct substitute for the commercial scenario.
Agree the deliverables before commissioning laboratory work
Ask for a written objective, product identification, rationale for the selected design, conditions, sampling schedule, measurements, acceptance or interpretation approach, report content and limits. Confirm what happens if a sample, storage condition or analysis departs from the plan. Establish who will review and approve the complete product decision after the laboratory reports.
For a challenge study, confirm the laboratory’s competence and containment arrangements. Pathogens and inoculated product belong in appropriate specialist facilities and must be kept out of commercial food production. This article provides no inoculation protocol or permission to experiment with pathogens in a food workplace.
Make the sample and report handover traceable. Keep the agreed plan, commercial batch references, dispatch and receipt information, original results, deviations and technical interpretation together. The food sample handover guide covers that record connection.
Use the conclusion within the product boundaries assessed
The business needs a documented conclusion linking the evidence to the proposed date and directions. Identify unresolved findings and the conditions under which the conclusion applies. Quality deterioration, packaging performance and relevant nutrient stability may also need evidence even when a defined pathogen question has been answered.
Record the formulation, process, packaging and storage conditions attached to the conclusion. A later change needs a review of whether the evidence still applies. Use the shelf-life reassessment guide for that separate change decision.
Common commissioning mistakes include buying a standard panel before defining the question, treating absence in routine samples as proof of no growth, copying another product’s study conditions, or extending a date from a laboratory result without reviewing its scope. A useful pre-commissioning checklist is to identify the product, unresolved hazard question, existing evidence, study objective, agreed design, report deliverables and responsible reviewer.
Frequently asked questions
Does every chilled ready-to-eat food need a challenge test?
The study requirement depends on the actual hazards, product, existing evidence and applicable programme. A competent assessment should identify whether a challenge study is needed and what it must answer.
Can a durability study include microbiological testing?
Yes. It can follow the commercial food’s microbiological and other relevant characteristics during storage. Clarify which observations and tests are included in the agreed design.
Do non-detections prove that Listeria cannot grow?
A non-detection in sampled food does not demonstrate growth behaviour if the organism were present. Resolve that separate question with evidence appropriate to the product.
Can we run a pathogen challenge test in our production kitchen?
Commission appropriate specialist laboratory work. Keep pathogens and inoculated food outside commercial food production. Do not use this planning guide as an experimental procedure.
Does a successful growth study validate our cooking step?
Growth and treatment effectiveness are different questions. Have the specialist define which question the study answers and what other validation is needed.
Can AFVA perform the challenge analysis?
AFVA provides planning, sampling-plan support, laboratory coordination, evidence review and documentation. Required analysis is carried out by an appropriate external laboratory.
How AFVA can help
Bring your final product specification, process, pack, intended date and storage conditions, together with the evidence already available. AFVA can help turn the unresolved question into a clear study brief and coordinate suitable laboratory input within an agreed consulting scope.
General information only. Confirm the requirements that apply to your specific food activities, products, processes, locations and sales model.
Need Practical Food Safety Support for Your Business?
Contact us for free initial guidance. We provide practical, plain-English food safety support for New Zealand food businesses across all service areas.
This article provides general information only and is not a substitute for professional advice specific to your situation. Contact us for guidance based on your actual food activities and requirements.